Choosing the right real estate agent can make or break your experience when buying or selling a home. Whether you're a first-time home buyer or preparing to list your home, knowing how to pick the best REALTOR® is one of your most important decisions.
But how do you choose a REALTOR® you can trust? What should you look for in a real estate agent? In this guide, we'll walk you through everything you need to know about how to find a good REALTOR®—plus tips for narrowing your options and selecting the right partner for your journey.
Why Picking the Right REALTOR® Matters
Realtors are more than just licensed professionals—they're your advocates, advisors, and strategists. The best real estate agents confidently help you navigate pricing, paperwork, negotiations, and emotional ups and downs. Here's why choosing a REALTOR® carefully is so important:
- Local Expertise: A great REALTOR® knows the local market—inside and out. They'll help you understand neighborhoods, price trends, and red flags.
- Negotiation Power: An experienced agent knows how to get the best price and terms, whether you're buying or selling.
- Stress Reduction: From coordinating showings to managing timelines, a good REALTOR® keeps everything on track so you can focus on what matters most.
What to Look for in a REALTOR®
Start here if you're wondering, "What should I look for when choosing a REALTOR®?". These are the top qualities that define the best in the business:
1. Experience and Proven Results
When selecting a real estate agent, look for someone with a strong track record in your area. Ask how many transactions they've closed recently and whether they specialize in your property type. Reviews, testimonials, and referrals all help you get a sense of their reputation.
2. In-Depth Local Market Knowledge
A good REALTOR® knows more than just the basics—they understand schools, commute patterns, zoning quirks, and hidden gems. Local insight is especially crucial if you're relocating or buying in an unfamiliar area.
3. Strong Communication and Listening Skills
The best realtors don't just talk—they listen. Choose someone responsive, easy to understand, and tuned into your goals. Communication matters from day one through closing.
4. Integrity and Professionalism
You want someone who will represent your interests honestly and ethically. Ask whether they're a National Association of Realtors (NAR) member or other professional groups, which typically require a code of ethics.
5. Digital Know-How and Resourcefulness
Today's best real estate agents are savvy with technology—think virtual tours, online marketing, digital signing tools, and data-driven insights. They also have strong networks of lenders, inspectors, and contractors to support your journey.
How to Choose a REALTOR®: 5 Key Steps
1. Do Your Homework
Search online, compare websites, read reviews, and check credentials. Look for realtors with expertise in your price point and location. Many top agents also post videos or blog content that gives you a feel for their style.
2. Ask People You Trust
One of the best ways to find a good REALTOR® is to ask around. Friends, coworkers, and neighbors can share their honest experiences and help point you in the right direction.
3. Interview a Few Candidates
Don't stop with the first agent you meet. Talk to two or three realtors and compare how they communicate, their strategies, and how well they understand your needs. Prepare questions like:
- What's your experience in this market?
- What's your marketing approach?
- How do you handle bidding wars or tricky negotiations?
4. Check Licenses, References, and Reviews
Make sure your agent is licensed and in good standing. Ask for client references and take time to follow up. What you learn from past clients can help you avoid surprises.
5. Trust Your Gut
Picking a REALTOR® isn't just about stats—it's about trust and chemistry. If someone makes you feel pressured, unheard, or confused, keep looking. A strong agent relationship should feel like a partnership.
First-Time Buyer? Here's How to Pick a REALTOR® with Confidence
Choosing a real estate agent might be overwhelming if this is your first time buying a home. Look for someone who's worked with first-time buyers before and can break things down clearly. A great agent will guide you through every step, from getting pre-approved to navigating inspections, and make sure you feel supported the whole way.
Final Thoughts on Picking the Best REALTOR®
Choosing a real estate agent isn't just another checkbox—it's a decision that shapes your entire home buying or selling experience. The best realtors combine knowledge, strategy, and trustworthiness to help you succeed. By taking the time to research, ask questions, and trust your instincts, you'll find someone who feels like the right fit for you.
Related Reads:
Partner With a REALTOR® You Can Trust
At Dickson Realty, we know that picking the right REALTOR® can change everything. With offices in Reno, Carson City, Truckee, and across Northern Nevada and Lake Tahoe, our real estate agents are local experts dedicated to delivering results with integrity. Plus, as part of the Leading Real Estate Companies of the World® network, we connect you to top-tier professionals wherever your journey takes you.
